There are two regions in Mexico that are especially ideal for any first-time trip (or second or third time!)… the Yucatan Peninsula and Oaxaca State. However, both offer unique experiences, which can make it difficult to choose between them.

While there is never a true answer when it comes to whether one place is “better” than another, there are some definite differences between these two regions that can help you decide which is best for your next adventure.

Both regions have captured my heart in distinct ways, so I believe I can impartially give you the pros and cons of each.

Differences at a Glance

Yucatan Peninsula Oaxaca State
One of the most popular areas for tourists in Mexico Not exactly undiscovered (nowhere is!), but can offer a more authentic and traditional experience
Flat terrain; mostly plains and wetlands Highly mountainous
Beautiful beaches with calm waters, occasional issues with seaweed (explained below) Beautiful beaches with often rough waters (loved by surfers), with some calmer bays
Highly commercialized beaches in Cancun, Playa del Carmen & Isla Mujeres — with other more laidback places Moderately commercialized beaches in Puerto Escondido and Huatulco, with a variety of quieter beach towns
Cities: A smaller number of cultural attractions in Merida and Valladolid Cities: Rich history and culture in Oaxaca City
Numerous Mayan ruins (Chichén Itzá, Cobá, Ek Balam, etc.) The Zapotec ruins at Monte Albán
Perfect for snorkeling and scuba diving OK for snorkeling and scuba diving
Great for dolphin & whale watching (whale sharks too) Great for dolphin & whale watching
Good for foodies — as anywhere in Mexico! Amazing for foodies, particularly Oaxaca City

Yucatan Peninsula

The view above from underwater Cenote Azul in Mexico
Cenote Azul, Yucatan

The Yucatan Peninsula is an ideal destination for those seeking a mix of relaxation and adventure, with plenty of opportunities for water sports and exploration — including the chance to swim or dive in river caves called cenotes.

It’s also a very short flight from many major US cities, making it a convenient and affordable option for travelers.

Oaxaca State

Oaxaca is known for its vibrant indigenous culture, colorful markets, and delicious food. In fact, many consider Oaxaca City to be the culinary capital of Mexico.

Oaxaca State is great for those looking to immerse themselves in the local culture and try out new experiences, such as mezcal tasting or participating in traditional festivals. If you’re heading to Mexico in November, Dia de los Muertos (Day of the Dead) in Oaxaca is an unforgettable experience.

Let’s break it down even further to help you decide.

A man pouring mezcal into a shot glass held by another person

Wait… where are Oaxaca and the Yucatan?
To clarify: Oaxaca is both the name of a city and a state in the south of Mexico, but we’ll be looking at the whole state here.With ‘the Yucatan’ we mean the whole of the Yucatan Peninsula, which includes Yucatan State and Quintana Roo State in the southeast of Mexico. The coast here is often referred to as the Riviera Maya.

Yucatan vs Oaxaca: Beaches

It should be a crime to talk about travel in Mexico and not mention the stunning beaches. Both Yucatan and Oaxaca have beautiful coastlines, but they offer different experiences.

The seaside Mayan Ruins in Tulum
Mayan Ruins of Tulum, Yucatan Peninsula

The Yucatan is 100% more popular for its beaches than, I would say, the rest of Mexico. Known for its gorgeous crystal-clear waters and powder-white sand, it’s a paradise for beach lovers.

There are popular tourist locations such as Cancun and Playa del Carmen, but there are also many hidden gems and secluded beaches waiting to be explored. And although Tulum has become expensive and arguably overhyped, there are also many alternatives to Tulum.

Chen Rio Beach in Mexico
Chen Rio in Cozumel, Yucatán Peninsula

Every once in a while, the Yucatan coast suffers from sargassum washing ashore. This fairly smelly seaweed can diminish the “perfect paradise beach” aesthetic, at least if you’re so unlucky. However, the resorts make an effort to clean it up and you can also check the status of beaches on the official Facebook page.

Beach in Carazillo
Playa Manzanillo, Puerto Escondido

Meanwhile, Oaxaca’s beaches may not get as much attention, but they are equally stunning in their own way.

The most popular beach destination in Oaxaca is Puerto Escondido, famous for its world-class surfing waves. The sand is a nice golden color, and the vibes are top-notch.

An empty beach in Mazunte, Mexico
Mazunte, Oaxaca

You’ll get some of the most epic sunsets on the Pacific and a more laid-back and authentic beach experience. There are also quieter and more secluded options like Zipolite or Mazunte.

It should be said that the waves on the Pacific coast are quite fierce compared to the mostly gently lapping waves in the Yucatan. The waves are loved by surfers but not always by swimmers, but there are usually some secluded bays where it’s easier to swim.

Yucatan vs Oaxaca: Cities

The Kukulkan Pyramid in Mexico
Pyramid of Kukulcan in Chichen Itza, Yucatán Peninsula

While the Yucatan Peninsula is known for its popular beach destinations, it also has some incredible cities to explore. Merida, the capital of Yucatan, is known for its rich culture and history, stunning architecture, and delicious food. Valladolid is another gem in the Yucatan, offering a more tranquil and traditional vibe. It’s small, and one of the closest towns to the famous Chichen Itza ruins, making it a great option for a day trip.

Personally, I think Oaxaca State takes the crown when it comes to cities. Oaxaca City is one of the most inviting cities in all of Mexico. It has colorful buildings, bustling markets, and the most amazing cuisine. Every night, the streets are filled with vendors whipping up some of the best street food you’ll ever have.

Oaxaca also boasts a vibrant indigenous culture that infuses its art, music, and traditions. Unlike many cities in the Yucatan that have embraced highly commercialized tourism, Oaxaca remains a little truer to its authentic and local roots, making it ideal for an immersive cultural experience.

Yucatan vs Oaxaca: Nature

Ik-Kil cenote in Mexico
Ik-Kil Cenote, Yucatan

The Yucatan’s beaches are incredible, but the peninsula shines its brightest with its cenotes. These natural underground swimming holes have crystal-clear waters and are perfect for a refreshing dip on a hot day.

Some of my favorite cenotes in the Yucatan include Cenote Suytun, Ik Kil, and Dos Ojos.

In Oaxaca, nature takes on a different form. Instead of beaches and underground swimming holes, this region is known for its stunning mountain landscapes, lush forests, and impressive canyons. One of the must-visit natural attractions in Oaxaca is Hierve el Agua, a set of stunning rock formations resembling frozen waterfalls.

The mountains in Oaxaca offer many opportunities for hiking and trekking, in particular among the Pueblos Mancomunicados (joint villages) near Oaxaca City, and around the town of San José del Pacifico.

Yucatan vs Oaxaca: Accommodations & Prices

The Yucatan is extremely popular for all-inclusive resorts, which can be a great option for families or travelers looking for a more luxurious and convenient experience.

However, if you’re on a budget, you can still find hostels and Airbnbs at an affordable price. But because the Yucatan is so used to tourism, prices are going to be higher for just about everything—taxis, food, and activities.

The beach at XCaret Park in Yucatan, Mexico
XCaret Park in Riviera Maya, Yucatan Peninsula

Oaxaca State is a great alternative for travelers who want to avoid the high prices of tourist hotspots. Accommodations in Oaxaca range from budget-friendly hostels and guesthouses to boutique hotels and cozy bed and breakfasts.

You can also find unique accommodations like eco-lodges or haciendas, which offer a more authentic experience while still being affordable.

Accommodation in Oaxaca

As for budgeting, Oaxaca is generally more affordable than the Yucatan. Food, transportation, and activities tend to be cheaper in Oaxaca compared to touristy areas like Cancun or Playa del Carmen.

Yucatan vs Oaxaca: Travel Logistics

The Yucatan is much smaller and more compact compared to Oaxaca, which means it’s easier to visit multiple destinations in a shorter amount of time. This is ideal if you want to hit all the major tourist spots like Cancun, Tulum, and Chichen Itza without spending too much time in transit.

A road in Mexico being seen from inside a car
A road in Playa del Carmen, Yucatan Peninsula

Oaxaca is a larger state with more diverse landscapes and attractions. Some routes through the mountains can take a very long time; for instance, a bus from Oaxaca City to the coast used to take a whopping 9 to 11 hours. However, a new road opened in 2024 has shortened the travel time from Oaxaca City to the coastal city of Puerto Escondido to just 3 hours. This makes Oaxaca now easier to travel through than it’s ever been!

However, the Yucatan has one of Mexico’s most popular and well-connected airports, making it easier to fly directly from a huge range of international origins. To get to Oaxaca, you are more likely to have to travel via Mexico City, which may add extra time and cost to your trip.

Should You Visit the Yucatan or Oaxaca?

Honestly, it really depends on what you’re looking for out of your trip. After spending loads of time in both locations, I still have a hard time choosing a favorite. Even though Oaxaca is a little more my style, the Yucatan’s opportunities for adventure and relaxation can’t be denied.

If you’re a first-time traveler or have a tight schedule, the Yucatan may be your better option. But if you’re seeking a cultural experience at the heart of Mexico, then Oaxaca offers a unique and diverse experience that will surely leave you in awe.

Some links may be affiliate links, meaning I may earn commission from products or services I recommend. For more, see site policies.